Space Act Agreements - Space Law Journal https://spacelawjournal.com Law and regulation of outer space Tue, 17 Nov 2026 09:02:37 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4 https://spacelawjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/slj-site-icon-v2-150x150.png Space Act Agreements - Space Law Journal https://spacelawjournal.com 32 32 Protecting Your IP in “Coopetition” With Government Collaborative Programmes for Space https://spacelawjournal.com/space-coopetition-intellectual-property-government-programmes/ Tue, 17 Nov 2026 09:02:37 +0000 https://spacelawjournal.com/space-coopetition-intellectual-property-government-programmes/

The short version

  • Commercial space companies working on government and defence programmes increasingly work alongside competitors, which puts their patents, trade secrets and know-how at risk of disclosure.
  • Under 51 U.S.C. § 20135(b), an invention made under a NASA contract can become the property of the United States; NASA can waive title but keeps a royalty-free licence, and a waiver has to be applied for.
  • Government-launched commercial payloads do not automatically get government-use immunity from patent infringement claims under 28 U.S.C. § 1498, because of 51 U.S.C. § 20135(k).
  • Separate background IP from foreground IP, file (or at least file a provisional) before the collaboration starts, keep records of funding sources and run clean-team protocols when working with competitors.

The United States recently announced it will deploy weapons systems in space and establish the U.S. Space Academy to train the next generation of space warfare professionals. These initiatives signal an unprecedented expansion of national security space activities, thereby requiring demand for collaboration of commercial space companies with each other and the government. Companies that compete commercially may now find themselves working alongside competitors on classified defence projects, sharing facilities, technical reviews, and integration timelines while protecting their most valuable innovations from disclosure. This “coopetition,” or simultaneous competition and cooperation, creates significant intellectual property risks that require careful navigation. But the legal framework governing these arrangements has evolved considerably. These commercial space companies must consider how to fully participate in government programmes while safeguarding the patents, trade secrets, and proprietary know-how that help to define their competitive advantage.

From government-owned IP to negotiated rights

Under legacy contracting models, the government paid for development and either owned the resulting intellectual property outright or obtained broad licence rights. The Commercial Space Act of 1998 and the Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act of 2015 introduced more flexibility, recognising that companies investing their own capital deserve greater intellectual property protections. Today, Space Act Agreements and public-private partnerships offer more nuanced frameworks for intellectual property allocation, and understanding these mechanisms is essential for a commercial space company participating in government programmes.

What the NASA statute says about ownership

The statutory framework governing these arrangements demands close attention. Under 51 U.S.C. § 20135(b), an invention becomes the “exclusive property of the United States” if made under a NASA contract by an employee assigned to perform research and development work related to the contract. The NASA Administrator may waive these rights, but subject to retaining an irrevocable, nonexclusive, royalty-free worldwide licence. NASA’s patent waiver regulations at 14 CFR Part 1245 govern this process. Companies should understand that waiver is not automatic; it requires affirmative application and approval.

A critical provision for commercial operators is 51 U.S.C. § 20135(k), which provides that use or manufacture of patented inventions incorporated in a space vehicle launched by the U.S. Government for a person other than the United States “shall not be considered to be a use or manufacture by or for the United States” under 28 U.S.C. § 1498(a) unless NASA gives express authorisation or consent. This means commercial payloads riding on government-launched vehicles do not automatically receive government-use immunity from patent infringement claims.

Draw the line between background and foreground IP

Protecting your IP in this environment requires deliberate planning. Most fundamentally, clearly delineate background IP from foreground IP before entering any collaborative programme. Background IP, meaning technology you developed independently before the programme, should be documented and disclosed to the government as pre-existing. Foreground IP, meaning inventions made during and in performance of the contract, will be subject to the contract’s IP provisions. The clearer the line between these categories, the stronger your position in any subsequent ownership dispute.

File before you collaborate

Filing patent applications before entering collaborative programmes is one of the most effective tools for establishing ownership and demonstrating reduction to practice. A filed application with an established priority date creates a clear evidentiary record that the invention predates the collaboration, which is critical when you anticipate disclosing technology to competitors during joint activities. From a patent law perspective, a properly documented reduction to practice, whether actual (building and testing) or constructive (filing a patent application), establishes your priority as the inventor. This evidence becomes invaluable if disputes arise over whether an invention was truly “background” IP developed before the government programme or “foreground” IP developed during performance.

When government funding touches the invention

However, practitioners must carefully consider how government funding affects these determinations. If government funds contributed to any aspect of the invention’s development, including testing, validation, or refinement, the reduction to practice may be deemed to have occurred under the contract, potentially triggering government ownership rights under 51 U.S.C. § 20135(b) or the Bayh-Dole Act (35 U.S.C. §§ 200-212) for federally funded inventions. Companies should maintain meticulous records distinguishing work performed with private funds from work performed under government contracts. Where an invention was conceived before the contract but reduced to practice during performance using government resources, the ownership analysis becomes particularly complex. The safest approach is to complete reduction to practice and ideally file a patent application before government funding touches the technology.

Provisional applications when the deadline is close

When an invention is not yet fully developed but government collaboration is imminent, provisional patent applications offer a strategic middle ground. A provisional application establishes a priority date without requiring formal claims, an oath or declaration, or an information disclosure statement. The application need only provide a written description sufficient to enable a person skilled in the art to make and use the invention. For space technology companies facing an approaching collaboration deadline, a provisional application can secure a priority date for the core concept while allowing another twelve months to refine the technology and prepare a complete non-provisional application. This approach is particularly valuable when the company has conceived the invention and developed it to some degree but has not yet completed testing or finalised design details. The provisional filing creates constructive reduction to practice as of the filing date, establishing that the invention existed before the collaborative programme began, even if further development occurs during the programme.

Marking, negotiation and clean teams

Beyond filing strategy, rigorous operational practices are essential. Implement proper marking and disclosure protocols: mark all proprietary documents clearly, restrict access where contractually permitted, and maintain detailed records of what information was shared, with whom, and when. Negotiate IP provisions carefully in Space Act Agreements, which offer more flexibility than traditional FAR contracts. Push for provisions that protect your background IP, limit government licence rights to what is necessary for the programme’s objectives, and clarify ownership of jointly developed innovations.

When working alongside competitors, maintain clean-team protocols. These information barriers, sometimes called “firewalls” or “ethical walls,” prevent your proprietary information from reaching competitor personnel and vice versa. Document these protocols and ensure compliance through training and audits. Similarly, document all disclosures made during collaborative work by maintaining contemporaneous records of what technology was demonstrated, discussed, or shared in collaborative settings. If a dispute arises later about whether a competitor independently developed a similar technology or derived it from your disclosure, these records will be critical.

Collaboration without giving away the edge

Government collaboration is often essential for space companies, but it need not come at the cost of your competitive advantage. By understanding the statutory framework, filing strategically before collaborations begin, using provisional applications when timing is tight, maintaining clear records of funding sources and development timelines, and implementing rigorous IP management practices, companies can participate fully in collaborative programmes while maintaining the proprietary edge that drives their commercial success. For the related question of who owns inventions made in orbit itself, see the authors’ earlier piece, Inventions Made in Space: The Unsettled Law of Orbital Innovation.

About the authors

Eric Sophir, partner at Foley & Lardner LLP

Eric Sophir is an intellectual property partner with Foley & Lardner LLP, where he develops and implements strategies that obtain, protect, and monetize meaningful patents for startups to Fortune 50 companies. He is based in the firm’s Washington, D.C., office.
Gary Solomon, partner at Foley & Lardner LLP

Gary Solomon is an intellectual property partner with Foley & Lardner LLP. A member of the firm’s Electronics Practice, Gary advises clients on patent preparation, prosecution, and the monetization and protection of these intellectual property assets. Prior to becoming a patent attorney, he was a systems design engineer in the aerospace industry for a decade. He is based in the firm’s Dallas office.

Questions people actually ask


What is coopetition in the space industry?

Coopetition is simultaneous competition and cooperation. Commercial space companies that compete for business may find themselves working alongside each other on government and classified defence programmes, sharing facilities, technical reviews and integration timelines, which creates a risk that proprietary technology is disclosed to a competitor.


Who owns an invention made under a NASA contract?

Under 51 U.S.C. § 20135(b), an invention made under a NASA contract by an employee assigned to research and development work related to the contract becomes the exclusive property of the United States. The NASA Administrator may waive title, but NASA keeps an irrevocable, nonexclusive, royalty-free worldwide licence, and the waiver must be applied for under 14 CFR Part 1245.


Do commercial payloads on government-launched vehicles get immunity from patent claims?

Not automatically. 51 U.S.C. § 20135(k) provides that using or making a patented invention in a space vehicle launched by the US Government for someone other than the United States is not a use by or for the United States under 28 U.S.C. § 1498(a), unless NASA expressly authorises or consents to it.


What is the difference between background IP and foreground IP?

Background IP is technology a company developed independently before a government programme and should be documented and disclosed as pre-existing. Foreground IP is an invention made during and in performance of the contract, and it is subject to the contract’s IP provisions.


How can a provisional patent application help before a government collaboration?

A provisional application secures a priority date without formal claims, an oath or declaration, or an information disclosure statement. It gives the company twelve more months to refine the technology and file a full non-provisional application, while creating a constructive reduction to practice that shows the invention existed before the collaboration began.


Featured image: High Bay 2 of the Vehicle Assembly Building at NASA’s Kennedy Space Center on 16 August 2019, when Northrop Grumman became the building’s first commercial tenant under a Reimbursable Space Act Agreement. Photo: NASA, public domain.

]]>